Film festival buzz is common, but it took on another form with “Obsession.” On September 5, 2025, writer/director Curry Barker premiered his second full-length feature in the Midnight Madness section of the Toronto International Film Festival. Just a month later, Focus Features acquired the film for $14 million — not bad for a 25-year-old YouTube sketch comedian with a story based on “The Monkey’s Paw” short from The Simpsons’ “Treehouse of Horror” Halloween special. Even the passionate response at the initial screening at the Royal Alexandra Theater in Toronto didn’t capture how popular the “be careful what you wish for” horror love tale would be with audiences.
The film went on to gross over $500 million worldwide, leaving its mark as one of the most successful releases of 2026 and a pillar of the ongoing revitalization of in-person moviegoing. (even its own Fortnite skin and items). “Obsession” has also garnered serious awards buzz, with lead actress Inde Navarrette’s portrayal of the apple of Bear’s eye, but soon-possessed Nikki, continuing to leave a lasting impression on those who’ve seen the film.
Substream Magazine caught up with both Barker and Navarrette in Toronto at this year’s festival, where they both reflect on the film’s success and speak about ways in how they shaped Nikki’s character together.
“Obsession” has taken on a life of its own, to the point that it’s part of Halloween Horror Nights at Universal Studios. A lot of the film’s imagery, phrases, and topics have managed to stay in the pop culture conversation where things turn over quickly. It feels like so much time has passed since TIFF 2025, but the film has only been out worldwide for a few months.
It’s one thing to see something you created embraced feverishly in one screening, but how does it feel to see it multiplied a hundred times over across the world?
Navarrette: “We were just talking about how it’s its birthday. It’s really neat to see it grow up, see it start walking on its own, and see other people get to see it. It’s like we had a baby, and it’s its own thing that people have perceptions about. We can nourish it and try to have our understanding of it.”
Barker: “What’s really crazy is that for this moment in the baby’s life, it hadn’t come out in theaters yet. It didn’t even come out until May. There were so many months in between had no idea what the general public was going to think. We had one magical screening at TIFF and said, “Okay, now what? The conversation just changed drastically when it started to blow up at the box office.”
One relatable thing in this story is how human this friend group is. Bear doesn’t tell Nikki how he feels, but Ian doesn’t tell Bear they’ve hooked up. Sarah doesn’t tell Bear how she feels about him, etc. They aren’t perfect, and some of these secrets even directly cause their undoing. How important was it to preserve a sense of thorniness in how people relate to one another in the film and perhaps not say what they need to say?
Barker: “I wanted to write a friend group that felt lived-in and not so ‘Hollywoodified.” I feel like a lot of the friend groups we see in movies are besties like nothing could go wrong. It actually makes me roll my eyes sometimes. I may have gone a little too far in making it seem like they’re just a horrible example of a friend group. I think the result is that people say they can relate to this, even if it’s a little bit of exaggeration of what they deal with. A lot of friends withhold things from each other.”
Storybook Love? ‘Obsession’ Will Make You Think Twice About It
The scene where Bear drives Nikki home, chickens out, and then uses the One Wish Willow is an integral portal to the dark places where the film goes next. It’s intriguing in the way you both, from a directorial and acting perspective, play with the audience’s presumptions. Maybe the One Wish Willow didn’t have to be an option at all, but taking the choice away from Nikki is a point of no return. How did you both look to approach the ambiguity in this scene in a way that propels us forward to the madness soon after?
Navarrette: “There was such confidence and vulnerability in letting Curry be my eyes. I don’t see certain things while I’m performing that he does. It was really about leaning into it. Even if it didn’t make sense to me, I fully trusted him. It just has to make sense for the story. There were some times when I was watching Obsession back where I was like, I understand, but it wasn’t for me to understand it. It was for me to let go of control. Of course, there were moments when I went to Curry and said, “I have this idea”—then we talked about it. But there were moments when I definitely needed to trust fully.
That was a really big day because the entire movie is told solely through Bear’s perspective. Nikki’s hot-and-coldness is because that’s a personification of exactly what she is “portraying” to him. Bear doesn’t know how she feels, so he’s going to read it into something. It was really important because, at the beginning, I had to play a character without continuity. It’s a perception of her while still being a whole person. So, it’s a lot of contradictions and really just leaning on Curry in his brain, which I thought he did beautifully. There are moments where I’m like, “Yes, she is disappointed because maybe she does like Bear, or maybe she doesn’t. The point is that Bear didn’t have the courage to say anything.”
With that point in mind, is there a specific method where you both came together and wanted to portray Nikki’s ever-changing mental and physical state in a specific way to the audience?
Navarrette: “One thing that comes to mind is that Curry [Barker] was very specific about wanting Nikki’s full thought process to be seen on her face — so it’s not just a kiss and then “BOOM,”scare. It’s realizing you’re there and taking in your surroundings.”
Barker: “I would tell her to imagine Nikki is popping back into existence. She’s outside by the car; she’s confused. Now, she’s on the bed kissing Bear, looking around, like, ‘ What? I wanted her to take in your surroundings. Where are you? Who are you with? What’s going on? – and then let the fear set in.


